East Nine Bar & Grill at Fernandina Beach Golf Club
Have not had
David’s Restaurant & Lounge
Burlingame
POGO’s Kitchen
Bar Zin Bistro and Wine Bar
Baxter’s Restaurant
Nonna Mia at Omni Amelia Island
The Sprouting Project at Omni Amelia Island
Indigo
Sandbar Amelia Island
Kitchen 251
Mason’s Famous Lobster Rolls
Shuckers Oyster Bar & Grill
The Patio at 5th and Ash
Falcon’s Nest at Omni Amelia Island
Golf Pub Social
Garden Street Bistro
Surfcaster at Omni Amelia Island
The Back Porch Southern Eats
Tidewater Grill at The Ritz-Carlton
Savannah Pizza Company
Natural Slice at Omni Amelia Island
Coquina at The Ritz-Carlton
Bantam & Biddy
Cucina South
Philly Boyz Cheesesteaks
Eato Chef
Baba’s Mediterranean
Meal Ease Market
Magnolia’s Cafe
Seaglass at Omni Amelia Island
The Sound Cafe
Duck Pinz
The Lobby Bar at The Ritz-Carlton
Tiki Social at Surfcaster
Curry Island Indian Kitchen
Akari Sushi
Marché Côtier
Don Patron Mexican Grill
La Sureña Restaurant & Store
Mezcal Spirit of Oaxaca
New South Food Truck
The Bistro at Courtyard by Marriott Amelia Island
Georgia Smoke BBQ
Thirteen
Marsh View Bar and Grill
Tides Pool Bar and Grill
Leddy’s Porch Bistro
Thai Spice Cafe
Tigre Island Room
Mellow Yellow at Omni Amelia Island
Vintage Donuts
FloraBelle at Omni Amelia Island
Palmetto Press
Scully’s Irish Pub & Eatery
Paloma & Pico
Mini Drunken Noodle
1928 Cuban Bistro
Not enough food
Starbucks
Green Turtle Tavern
PJD’s Beer and Wine Garden
Mocama Beer Company
The Decantery
Amelia Island Coffee
The Palace Saloon
Mocama Coffee
Hammerhead Beach Bar
Holy Grounds Coffee House
Locals’ Cocktail Lounge
First Love Brewing
Story & Song Bookstore Bistro
Island Time Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt
Amelia Fresh Cafe
A1A Cidery
Nana Teresa’s Bake Shop
DeNucci’s
GoJuice
Twisted Table
Mimi’s Coffee and Boba Tea
Fernandina’s Fantastic Fudge
A Will and A Whisk Bakery LLC
The Principal’s Office Bar at Amelia Schoolhouse Inn
Ash Street Cigar Parlor
Marlin and Barrel Distillery
Dunkin’
Kismet Coffee
Created May 27, 2026
Create your ultimate amelia restaurants tier list and rank everything from S tier to D tier. This amelia restaurants ranking tool lets you compare, vote, and share your tier list with the community. Looking for the best amelia restaurants? Use this tier list to settle the debate and see how your amelia restaurants rankings stack up against other users on TierBuddy. Popular categories include restaurants, american-food, italian-restaurants, ohio-restaurants.