Menu

Best Cookies Ever Tier List

S
Chocolate chip cookies
white chocolate macadamia nut
oreo
A
Lofthouse cookies
B
snickerdoodle
Fortune cookies
C
Gingerbread cookies (men)
D
Oatmeal rasin
sugar cookies
F
Jam sandwich cookies (heart cutout)
cap'n crunch
Created May 12, 2026
The definitive best cookies ever tier list - rank, compare, and debate the best and worst best cookies ever. Place each item from S (GOATed) to D (bottom tier) and share your best cookies ever rankings. Made for fans who love ranking best cookies ever, this tier list maker is free, easy to use, and perfect for settling debates on TierBuddy. Popular categories include food, baking, desserts, american-snacks.

By TierBuddy Community

S Tier

A Tier

B Tier

C Tier

D Tier

F Tier