Menu

Coaches who could have made the Super Bowl if they had the easiest schedule since 1999, Josh McDaniels, Drake Maye, and played 3 teams decimated by injuries in the playoffs

S
Sean Payton
Sean McVay
Kyle Shanahan
Andy Reid
A
Mike Tomlin
John Harbaugh
Mike Macdonald
Liam Coen
Dan Campbell
Nick Sirianni
Jim Harbaugh
Mike Vrabel
B
Pete Carroll
Ben Johnson
DeMeco Ryans
Matt LeFleur
Kevin O’Connell
Sean McDermott
Mike McDaniel
Dan Quinn
C
Mike McCarthy
Brian Daboll
Kellen Moore
Kevin Stefanski
D
Brian Schottenheimer
Shane Steichen
Jonathan Gannon
Aaron Glenn
Brian Callahan
Raheem Morris
Dave Canales
Zac Taylor
Todd Bowles
IDK
Jesse Minter
Jeff Hafley
Created Mar 17, 2026
This provocative ranking examines which NFL coaches could have replicated a Super Bowl run given extraordinarily favorable circumstances: the league's easiest schedule since 1999, Josh McDaniels as offensive coordinator, rookie sensation Drake Maye at quarterback, and facing three injury-depleted playoff opponents.

The list features a who's who of current NFL coaching talent, from established champions like Andy Reid and Sean Payton to rising stars like Ben Johnson and DeMeco Ryans. It also includes proven playoff performers such as Kyle Shanahan, Mike Tomlin, and both Harbaugh brothers. The ranking sparks debate about whether success stems from coaching brilliance or fortunate circumstances, challenging fans to consider how much easier paths to glory might elevate different coaches' legacies. Which coaches would capitalize on such advantages, and which might still fall short?

(This description was AI-generated)

By mem060309

S Tier

A Tier

B Tier

C Tier

D Tier

IDK Tier