Menu
CreateCategoriesUpgradeArticles

Creepypasta

S
Penpal
Turn It Off
Mother Horse Eyes
The Stairs in the Woods
Stolen Tongues
Ensorcelled in the Earth
The Only Other Astronaut On This Mission Died
Journal of a Coal Miner's Daughter
A
My Husband/Wife has Taken Our Roleplaying
Jeff the Killer (Pastra rewrite)
Left Right Game
Feed the Pig
The Whistlers
Drumming in the Clouds
I'm Blind, I'm Not Sure How Many Steps
Fleshgait
Journal of an Unknown Soldier
I Found the Bunker of a Prepper Family
B
Ted the Caver
Tales from the Gas Station
The Whistler at 3:03 A.M
My Dad Ate Meat From a Deer
My Wife's Been Peeking at Me
Candle Cove
Rat King
Accounts from a Lonely Broadcast
Dogscape
Dreams Beneath the Witch Tree
Glenmont Metro
Tommy Taffy
C
It Breathes, It Bleeds, It Breeds
My Dog was Missing for Three Days
Gr3gory88
Burgrr Entries
Room 733
The Russian Sleep Experiment
Azalea's Cookhouse
The Showers
D
Lavender Town Syndrome
Psychosis
The Thing in the Basement
Smiling Ones
Smile Dog
The Rake
My Dead Girlfriend Keeps Messaging Me
NoEnd House
1999
E
Goatman
Jane the Killer
My Job is Watching a Woman
Jeff the Killer (original)
Eyeless Jack
Ickbarr Bigelsteine
Laughing Jack
Licking
Squidward's Suicide
Ben Drowned
Ticci Toby
Dead Bart
F
Sonic.exe
I Dared my Best Friend
Happy Appy
Created Feb 24, 2026
Unordered in the tier list, a ranking of creepypastas that I mostly got from Creepcast.

By TierBuddy Community

S Tier

A Tier

B Tier

C Tier

D Tier

E Tier

F Tier