Use this creepypasta characters: who's scariest? tier list to rank your favorites from best to worst. Drag items into S, A, B, C, or D tiers and share your creepypasta characters: who's scariest? rankings with friends. Whether you're debating the best creepypasta characters: who's scariest? or settling an argument, this tier list maker lets you create the perfect creepypasta characters: who's scariest? ranking and compare with other Americans on TierBuddy. Popular categories include horror, creepypasta, scary-movies, horror-movies.