Menu

Creepypastas Tier List

Make this a movie NOW
I'd read this if it was a book
By the Light of the Firefly
not my top pick
A New Kind of Year
someone actually posted this?
bleach my mind of this atrocity
Created May 6, 2026
The definitive creepypastas tier list - rank, compare, and debate the best and worst creepypastas. Place each item from S (GOATed) to D (bottom tier) and share your creepypastas rankings. Made for fans who love ranking creepypastas, this tier list maker is free, easy to use, and perfect for settling debates on TierBuddy. Popular categories include horror, stories, creepypasta-stories, scary-stories.

By TierBuddy Community

Make this a movie NOW Tier

I'd read this if it was a book Tier

not my top pick Tier

someone actually posted this? Tier

bleach my mind of this atrocity Tier