Menu

Creepypastas Tier List

S
Candle Cove
Lavender Town Syndrome
Slenderman
A
The Rake
Laughing Jack
Herobrine
B
Eyeless Jack
Sonic.exe
C
Jeff the Killer
D
Ticci Toby
...
Created Sep 12, 2026
The definitive creepypastas tier list - rank, compare, and debate the best and worst creepypastas. Place each item from S (GOATed) to D (bottom tier) and share your creepypastas rankings. Made for fans who love ranking creepypastas, this tier list maker is free, easy to use, and perfect for settling debates on TierBuddy.

By Ethan Hajek

S Tier

A Tier

B Tier

C Tier

D Tier

... Tier