Navigating the dating scene can feel like a minefield, but this tier list breaks down potential romantic interests into digestible categories. From the reliable and sweet Mabel to the exciting but perhaps unpredictable Izzy, discover who might be a keeper and who's best left as a fleeting encounter. We're ranking Peyton, Izzy, Navy, Mabel, and Abby based on their potential for a lasting relationship, fun dates, or just a good time. Will Abby be your soulmate or is Navy just a summer fling? Let's find out!