Stinky
Scary
Buff
Cool
Chill
Created Oct 23, 2025
Rank the most notorious commanders in Magic: The Gathering based on their "stink factor" – that dreaded reputation that makes opponents groan when you reveal your commander. From the eye-rolling combo potential of Ulalek and Zimone to the salt-inducing shenanigans of Admiral Brass and Isshin, this ranking captures which legendary creatures inspire the most table-wide sighs.
Whether it's the oppressive control of Teysa Karlov, the explosive value engines like Yarok the Desecrated, or the surprisingly spicy picks like Gluntch the Bestower, every deck has its own level of "stink." Some commanders draw immediate hate, while others fly under the radar before dominating the game. Featuring over 50 legendary creatures spanning multiple sets and playstyles, discover where your favorite (or most despised) commanders land on the odor scale of competitive casual play.
(This description was AI-generated)
Whether it's the oppressive control of Teysa Karlov, the explosive value engines like Yarok the Desecrated, or the surprisingly spicy picks like Gluntch the Bestower, every deck has its own level of "stink." Some commanders draw immediate hate, while others fly under the radar before dominating the game. Featuring over 50 legendary creatures spanning multiple sets and playstyles, discover where your favorite (or most despised) commanders land on the odor scale of competitive casual play.
(This description was AI-generated)
