First Line Shaving (Imperial Wagyu Base) (TIED for First)
Saponifico Varesino (TIED for First)
Wet Shaving Products- Formula T
Wholly Caw Siero Base
BBS
AE Legacy (TIED for Fifth)
Strike Gold Shaving (TIED for Fifth)
Gentleman's Nod (OLD Cardinal Base)
Cajun Blade Branford Base (1st version)
House of Mammoth
A+
HCC (old and new base)
Southern Witchcrafts
Hoffman's
Elysian
Murphy and McNeil Slainte Base
Declaration Grooming
Noble Otter
BCS Soap (OG pre TACL base)
Wet Shaving Store
AE Ultima 2
Nomad Theory
A-
PAA CK1
Heritage Hill
Shannon Soap (Chupacabra Base)
Adopted Acres (Grand Champion Base)
PAA CK6
TOBS
Subtle Arts
Tabac
B
Hags (Cortex X base)
Master Soap Creations
Hags (old base)
AE VR1 & VR2 (Vegan Base)
Wet the Face
Adopted Acres Old Base (no lard)
Barrister & Man (NOT omnibus base)
Chiseled Face
Soap Commander
Maggard's
Cella
C
Bricktown Grooming
AE K2E (Tallow)
Zingari Man
Van Yulay
Stirling (Beeswax)
Stirling (Mutton)
Central Texas Soaps
Rex Supply Co (Vegan)
Catie's Bubbles
Razor Emporium
Stirling (Regular Base)
Mama Bear Soap
345 Soap
Created May 21, 2026
Rank the best favorite soap scents with this free tier list maker. Drag and drop into S through D tiers to create your own favorite soap scents tier list, then share your results and see how your picks compare. Join thousands of US users ranking favorite soap scents on TierBuddy - the #1 tier list maker for favorite soap scents rankings, comparisons, and debates. Popular categories include soap, beauty, skincare, soap-brands.