The ultimate showdown of spooky season sweets has arrived! From the divisive candy corn, a polarizing pumpkin-spiced staple, to the universally beloved Reese's Peanut Butter Cups, this list dives deep into the heart of Halloween candy. We're ranking the iconic treats that make trick-or-treating so sweet, and the ones that might leave you feeling a little… empty-handed. Will your favorite crunchy chocolate bar or creamy peanut butter delight reign supreme? Prepare for a delicious debate as we sort the trick from the treat in this definitive Halloween candy ranking.