Rank your favorite Halloween haul treats from the ultimate chocolate classics to the disappointing non-candy surprises! This ranking features beloved trick-or-treating staples like Reese's Peanut Butter Cups and KitKat, alongside the divisive Tootsie Rolls that somehow always end up in your bag. Dairy Milk represents the premium chocolate tier, while the infamous Pencil & Eraser combo reminds us of those houses that gave out school supplies instead of sweets. Whether you're team chocolate, team chewy candy, or still traumatized by receiving stationery on Halloween night, this tier list lets you settle the age-old debate about which treats deserve top-tier status and which ones belong at the bottom of your plastic pumpkin bucket.