Menu

Heathers The Musical Songs Tier List

S
Candy Store
Meant To Be Yours
Freeze Your Brain
Never Shut Up Again
My Dead Gay Son
Dead Girl Walking
Seventeen
A
Beautiful
Big Fun
Our Love Is God
Shine A Light
B
Lifeboat
The Me Inside Of Me
I Say No
Dead Girl Walking Reprise
C
I Am Damaged
Youre Welcome
Shine A Light Reprise
D
Kindergarten Boyfriend
Fight For Me
Seventeen Reprise
Created May 21, 2026
The definitive heathers the musical songs tier list - rank, compare, and debate the best and worst heathers the musical songs. Place each item from S (GOATed) to D (bottom tier) and share your heathers the musical songs rankings. Made for fans who love ranking heathers the musical songs, this tier list maker is free, easy to use, and perfect for settling debates on TierBuddy. Popular categories include musicals, theater, broadway, musical-songs.

By Daisy Hawton

S Tier

A Tier

B Tier

C Tier

D Tier