By Chappell

In the MF House! Tier

Feeling it Tier

Bye Pumkin Tier

Time is Up! Tier

Menu
CreateCategoriesUpgradeArticles

I Love New York

In the MF House!
Tango nickname.png - I Love New York tier list item
Mr Boston Nickname.png - I Love New York tier list item
Chance Nickname.png - I Love New York tier list item
Feeling it
Pootie Nickname.png - I Love New York tier list item
Real Nickname.png - I Love New York tier list item
Onix Nickname.png - I Love New York tier list item
Whiteboy Nickname.png - I Love New York tier list item
T-Weed.png - I Love New York tier list item
Trendz.png - I Love New York tier list item
Rico nickname.png - I Love New York tier list item
Bye Pumkin
Heat Nickname.png - I Love New York tier list item
Token.png - I Love New York tier list item
Romance Nickname.png - I Love New York tier list item
Bonez.png - I Love New York tier list item
12 Pack Nickname.png - I Love New York tier list item
Time is Up!
Ace Nickname.png - I Love New York tier list item
Jersey Nickname.png - I Love New York tier list item
T-Money Nickname.png - I Love New York tier list item
Wood Nickname.png - I Love New York tier list item
T-Bone Nickname.png - I Love New York tier list item
Chappell
Chappell
Created Jan 30, 2026
Rank the unforgettable contestants from VH1's iconic reality dating show "I Love New York," where Tiffany "New York" Pollard searched for love among twenty colorful suitors. From fan favorites like Tango, Chance, and Real to controversial figures like Mr. Boston and 12 Pack, each contestant brought their own unique personality and drama to the mansion. Whether you're team Pootie, rooting for Romance, or can't forget the antics of Whiteboy and Heat, this ranking celebrates one of reality TV's most entertaining dating competitions. Relive the nicknames, the drama, and the moments that made this VH1 series a cultural phenomenon in the mid-2000s reality TV landscape.

(This description was AI-generated)