By Emily Merritt

Smash Tier

Pass Tier

??? Tier

Menu
CreateCategoriesUpgradeArticles

Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List

Smash
Plimbo - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Zagreus - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Trobbio - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Player Character, Sifu - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Skogsra - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Sonar - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Angela, American Arcadia - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Gwyndoline Roottree - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
The Cryptmaster - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
The Hiker - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Joanie - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Harrison James, Crow Country - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Gala, Coffee Talk - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Holly, The Wolf Among Us - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Krill - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Trevor, American Arcadia - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
FBI Director, Jazz Punk - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Octodad - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Poppea Pecorina - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Delilah, Firewatch - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Diya, Thirsty Suitors - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Persephone, Stray Gods - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Pan, Stray Gods - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Painter, TABS - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Fishmonger, Dredge - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Mr Toad, The Wolf Among Us - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Busker Robot, Stray - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Mentor, Many Nights a Whisper - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Sammy Lawrence, Bendy and the Ink Machine - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Shovel Knight - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Pineapple, Pizza Tower - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
The Duchess, Sorry We're Closed - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Stanley, The Stanley Parable - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Narrator, Stanley Parable - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Sedan, Keep Driving - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
The Goo, World of Goo - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Metal Detector, Blue Prince - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Bartender, SUPERHOT - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Alda, Baladins - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Pass
Mortaccio - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Researcher, Dredge - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Eugene McQuacklin - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
The Traveler, Chants of Sennaar - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Alice Angel - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Frog Dad, Cozy Caravan - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Miracle Roottree the 3rd - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Freddy - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Demon, The Mortuary Assistant - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Sergio, Thirsty Suitors - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Giovanna Grana - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Frank Coleman, Lake - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
The Devil, Indika - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Poe Ratcho - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
The Traveler, Journey - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Papouli - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
HS Sinclair, Blue Prince - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Soundie, Thirsty Suitors - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Bear, What the Car - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Neil, Coffee Talk - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Biker Wolf Pack, Sayonara Wild Hearts - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Natalie Crow, Crow Country - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Filbo Fiddlepie - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Pirate Queen, TABS - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Slick Mickey - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Shakra, Silksong - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Rusty, Rusty's Retirement - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
The Mountain King, Bramble: The Mountain King - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Jessie, Viewfinder - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Weird Guy, Clickolding - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Dreameater, Sorry We're Closed - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
???
Maureen Hennesy, Lake - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Baseball Card - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Ábramar - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Raymond - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
The Boat, Spilled! - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
The Woman, Her Story - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Your Host, Lorelei and the Laser Eyes - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
The One Who Waits, Cult of the Lamb - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Peppino, Pizza Tower - Indie Game Characters Smash or Pass Tier List tier list item
Emily Merritt
Emily Merritt
Created May 9, 2026
Ever wondered which indie game characters would make your heart skip a beat or which ones you'd rather just forget? This "Smash or Pass" tier list dives deep into the charming, the quirky, and the downright captivating personalities from the indie gaming universe. From the adventurous Zagreus and the enigmatic Traveler to the adorable Filbo Fiddlepie and the stylish Sifu, we're ranking them all. Will your favorite character land in the "Smash" category, or will they be relegated to the "Pass" pile? Let's find out which digital darlings have stolen the hearts of gamers everywhere.

(This description was AI-generated)