Menu
CreateCategoriesUpgradeArticles

ND Suspects

All Timer
lillian weiss image 2 - ND Suspects tier list item
dexter egan image 3 - ND Suspects tier list item
lisa ostrum image 2 - ND Suspects tier list item
simone mueller nancy image 3 - ND Suspects tier list item
nicholas falcone nancy image 3 - ND Suspects tier list item
brady armstrong image 3 - ND Suspects tier list item
linda penvellyn image 17 - ND Suspects tier list item
rachel hubbard nancy image 5 - ND Suspects tier list item
corine meyers nancy image 5 - ND Suspects tier list item
rentaro nancy image 9 - ND Suspects tier list item
miwako nancy image 3 - ND Suspects tier list item
yumi nancy drew image 3 - ND Suspects tier list item
elisabet nancy drew image 5 - ND Suspects tier list item
soren nancy image 5 - ND Suspects tier list item
jane penvellyn image 2 - ND Suspects tier list item
minette nancy image 1 - ND Suspects tier list item
anja nancy drew image 1 - ND Suspects tier list item
Solid
connie watson nancy drew image 5 - ND Suspects tier list item
dwayne powers image 5 - ND Suspects tier list item
millie strathorn image 6 - ND Suspects tier list item
abby sidaris nancy image 5 - ND Suspects tier list item
beatrice hotchkiss image 1 - ND Suspects tier list item
joseph hughes nancy image 3 - ND Suspects tier list item
joanna riggs image 2 - ND Suspects tier list item
taylor sinclair image 5 - ND Suspects tier list item
takae nancy drew image 2 - ND Suspects tier list item
emily griffin nancy image 1 - ND Suspects tier list item
red knott nnancy image 5 - ND Suspects tier list item
joy trent nancy image 3 - ND Suspects tier list item
jenna deblin nancy image 3 - ND Suspects tier list item
short thurmond nancy image 1 - ND Suspects tier list item
ethel bossiny image 1 - ND Suspects tier list item
letitia drake image 1 - ND Suspects tier list item
jane willougby nancy image 2 - ND Suspects tier list item
charleena purcell nancy image 1 - ND Suspects tier list item
j j ling nancy image 1 - ND Suspects tier list item
big island mike nancy image 3 - ND Suspects tier list item
quigley kim image 1 - ND Suspects tier list item
henry bolet image 5 - ND Suspects tier list item
buford nancy drew image 5 - ND Suspects tier list item
renee amand nancy image 1 - ND Suspects tier list item
helena berg nancy image 3 - ND Suspects tier list item
kyler malloy image 15 - ND Suspects tier list item
kit foley nancy image 3 - ND Suspects tier list item
fiona nancy drew image 4 - ND Suspects tier list item
mel corbalis image 7 - ND Suspects tier list item
izzy romero nancy image 9 - ND Suspects tier list item
scott nancy drew image 5 - ND Suspects tier list item
debbie kircum image 3 - ND Suspects tier list item
lukas nancy image 1 - ND Suspects tier list item
karl nancy drew image 5 - ND Suspects tier list item
renate nancy drew image 5 - ND Suspects tier list item
alexei nancy image 2 - ND Suspects tier list item
toni nancy drew image 2 - ND Suspects tier list item
grey nancy drew deadly image 2 - ND Suspects tier list item
clara thornton image 15 - ND Suspects tier list item
harper thornton image 5 - ND Suspects tier list item
dagny nancy drew image 9 - ND Suspects tier list item
gunnar nancy image 9 - ND Suspects tier list item
Your Average (Frank &) Joe
daryl gray nancy image 3 - ND Suspects tier list item
hulk sanchez nancy image 5 - ND Suspects tier list item
ingrid corey image 3 - ND Suspects tier list item
rick arlen image 1 - ND Suspects tier list item
rose green nancy image 5 - ND Suspects tier list item
jacques nancy drew image 5 - ND Suspects tier list item
henrik van der hune image 3 - ND Suspects tier list item
alejandro del rio nancy image 3 - ND Suspects tier list item
jeff akers nancy image 3 - ND Suspects tier list item
elliott chen nancy image 1 - ND Suspects tier list item
harlan bishop image 3 - ND Suspects tier list item
katie firestone image 5 - ND Suspects tier list item
holt scotto image 1 - ND Suspects tier list item
tex britten image 3 - ND Suspects tier list item
mary yazzi image 1 - ND Suspects tier list item
nigel mookerjee image 3 - ND Suspects tier list item
emily crandall nancy image 1 - ND Suspects tier list item
joe archer nancy image 3 - ND Suspects tier list item
balducci last train nancy image 1 - ND Suspects tier list item
fatima nancy image 1 - ND Suspects tier list item
heather mckay nancy image 1 - ND Suspects tier list item
pua mapu image 2 - ND Suspects tier list item
malachi craven image 1 - ND Suspects tier list item
guadalupe nancy image 3 - ND Suspects tier list item
lamont warrick nancy image 3 - ND Suspects tier list item
marguerita nancy image 3 - ND Suspects tier list item
donal delaney nancy image 14 - ND Suspects tier list item
leela yadav image 9 - ND Suspects tier list item
pa nancy drew image 3 - ND Suspects tier list item
chase nancy drew image 5 - ND Suspects tier list item
frosty nancy drew image 3 - ND Suspects tier list item
deidre nancy image 1 - ND Suspects tier list item
brenda nancy drew image 8 - ND Suspects tier list item
lily nancy drew image 8 - ND Suspects tier list item
jamila nancy drew image 5 - ND Suspects tier list item
mason nancy drew image 3 - ND Suspects tier list item
ryan nancy drew deadly device image 3 - ND Suspects tier list item
ellie york nancy image 3 - ND Suspects tier list item
victor nancy drew image 3 - ND Suspects tier list item
wade thornton image 9 - ND Suspects tier list item
alec fell nancy image 5 - ND Suspects tier list item
moira nancy drew image 11 - ND Suspects tier list item
niobe nancy image 8 - ND Suspects tier list item
Utterly Forgettable
hal tanaka image 3 - ND Suspects tier list item
mitch dillon nancy image 11 - ND Suspects tier list item
detective beech nancy image 9 - ND Suspects tier list item
mattie jensen image 5 - ND Suspects tier list item
louis chandler nancy image 4 - ND Suspects tier list item
charlie nancy drew image 7 - ND Suspects tier list item
andy jason nancy image 3 - ND Suspects tier list item
dave gregory nancy image 3 - ND Suspects tier list item
richard topham nancy image 1 - ND Suspects tier list item
john grey nancy image 5 - ND Suspects tier list item
dieter nancy image 5 - ND Suspects tier list item
jean michele nancy image 1 - ND Suspects tier list item
lou talbot nancy image 1 - ND Suspects tier list item
ollie randall nancy image 2 - ND Suspects tier list item
bill kessler nancy image 1 - ND Suspects tier list item
enrico nancy drew image 1 - ND Suspects tier list item
matt simmons nancy image 5 - ND Suspects tier list item
dylan nancy drew image 2 - ND Suspects tier list item
colton nancy drew image 1 - ND Suspects tier list item
jessalyn nancy drew image 1 - ND Suspects tier list item
ewan nancy drew image 2 - ND Suspects tier list item
kiri nind image 3 - ND Suspects tier list item
patrick nancy drew image 7 - ND Suspects tier list item
leena nancy drew image 5 - ND Suspects tier list item
magnus nancy image 9 - ND Suspects tier list item
No Thanks
lori girard image 3 - ND Suspects tier list item
colin nancy drew image 1 - ND Suspects tier list item
dwayne powers ransom image 7 - ND Suspects tier list item
abdullah nancy image 2 - ND Suspects tier list item
bridget zoe nancy image 3 - ND Suspects tier list item
sonny joon image 3 - ND Suspects tier list item
xenia nancy drew image 1 - ND Suspects tier list item
grigor nancy image 9 - ND Suspects tier list item
thanos nancy image 2 - ND Suspects tier list item
Created Jan 12, 2026
Rank your favorite suspects from the beloved Nancy Drew mystery game series! From the charming but suspicious Ned Nickerson stand-ins to truly sinister culprits, this collection features over 100 memorable characters who've crossed paths with our favorite teen detective.

Whether you're rating classic suspects like Hal Tanaka and Henrik van der Hune, or more recent additions like the Thornton family members (Clara, Harper, and Wade), each character brought their own intrigue to Nancy's investigations. Some were red herrings with hearts of gold, while others proved to be genuinely dangerous adversaries.

Organize these suspects by how memorable they were, how guilty they seemed, or simply how much you enjoyed (or despised) interacting with them throughout your sleuthing adventures!

(This description was AI-generated)

By TierBuddy Community

All Timer Tier

Solid Tier

Your Average (Frank &) Joe Tier

Utterly Forgettable Tier

No Thanks Tier