From the marching band powerhouses of Grambling State and the University of Arizona to the pop spectacle of Rihanna and the sheer energy of Usher, Super Bowl halftime shows have delivered unforgettable moments. This ranking dives deep into the archives, evaluating everything from iconic performances by artists like Eminem and Bad Bunny to the often-overlooked, yet historically significant, early shows and the incredible precision of university marching bands. Get ready to debate which acts truly hit a touchdown and which ones fumbled the ball on the biggest stage in entertainment.