Good

Poppy

Kissy missy

Dogday

Playtime butcher

Misunderstood

Huggy wuggy

Bunzo bunny

Doey the dough man

Outamals

Broken

Catnap

Smiling criters

Bron

Evil

The prototype

Mini huggys

Pure evil

Lily lovebradies

Mommy long legs

PJ pugaceler

Docter

Nightmare criters

Created Mar 26, 2026

Use this poppy playtime tier list to rank your favorites from best to worst. Drag each item into S through D tiers, share your rankings, and compare with other users on TierBuddy.

By TierBuddy Community

Good Tier

Poppy
Kissy missy
Dogday
Playtime butcher

Misunderstood Tier

Huggy wuggy
Bunzo bunny
Doey the dough man
Outamals

Broken Tier

Catnap
Smiling criters
Bron

Evil Tier

The prototype
Mini huggys

Pure evil Tier

Lily lovebradies
Mommy long legs
PJ pugaceler
Docter
Nightmare criters