Hunstman - Sheriff Graham.webp

Jefferson _ Mad Hatter.webp

Killian Hook.webp

Fredrick.webp

Henry Mills.webp

Pinocchio _ August Booth.webp

Felix.webp

Rumplestiltskin.webp

Victor Frankenstein _ Dr Whale.webp

Gideon.webp

King Arthur.webp

Kristoff.webp

Neal Cassidy.webp

Prince Charming _ David Nolan.webp

Sheriff Of Nottingham - Keith.webp

Daniel Colter.webp

Gaston.webp

Grumpy _ Leroy.webp

Liam.webp

Mr Hyde.webp

Peter Pan.webp

Archie Hopper _ Jiminy Cricket.webp

Dr Jekyll.webp

Grand Pabbie.webp

Hades.webp

Hans.webp

King Fergus.webp

Lumiere.webp

Created Jan 27, 2026

Ever wondered how the leading men of Storybrooke stack up against each other? From the swashbuckling Captain Hook to the morally complex Rumplestiltskin, Once Upon a Time delivered an incredible roster of male characters spanning multiple fairy tale realms. This ranking evaluates fan favorites like Prince Charming, the tragic Huntsman/Sheriff Graham, and the enigmatic Jefferson (Mad Hatter), alongside villains like Peter Pan and Hades. Whether you're team Hero with characters like Henry Mills and Kristoff, or prefer the darker charm of Mr. Hyde and Gaston, every OUAT fan has strong opinions about these beloved (and sometimes despised) characters. Time to settle the debate about who truly deserves the top spot in the Enchanted Forest!

(This description was AI-generated)

By TierBuddy Community

S Tier

Hunstman - Sheriff Graham.webp
Jefferson _ Mad Hatter.webp
Killian Hook.webp

A Tier

Fredrick.webp
Henry Mills.webp
Pinocchio _ August Booth.webp
Felix.webp
Rumplestiltskin.webp
Victor Frankenstein _ Dr Whale.webp

B Tier

Gideon.webp
King Arthur.webp
Kristoff.webp
Neal Cassidy.webp
Prince Charming _ David Nolan.webp
Sheriff Of Nottingham - Keith.webp

C Tier

Daniel Colter.webp
Gaston.webp
Grumpy _ Leroy.webp
Liam.webp
Mr Hyde.webp
Peter Pan.webp

D Tier

Archie Hopper _ Jiminy Cricket.webp
Dr Jekyll.webp
Grand Pabbie.webp
Hades.webp
Hans.webp
King Fergus.webp
Lumiere.webp