Menu
CreateCategoriesUpgradeArticles

Taylor Debut

Sweeter than Fiction
Mary's Song (Oh My My My)
Stay Beautiful
A (Oh my what a marvelous tune)
Cold As You
The Outside
A Place In This World
Our Song
I'm Only Me When I'm with You
B (A perfectly good song)
Tim McGraw
A Perfectly Good Heart
Invisible
C (It isnt love it isnt hate its just indifference
Teardrops on My Guitar
Picture to Burn
D (Is It Over Now?)
E (I forgot that this existed)
F (The Last Time I'll listen to this)
Shouldve Said No
Sad (This is me crying)
Tied Together with a Smile
Mudkip
Mudkip
Created Jan 21, 2026
Rank your favorite tracks from Taylor Swift's self-titled debut album that launched a superstar! Released in 2006, this collection introduced the world to a then-teenage songwriter with a gift for storytelling and country-pop melodies. From the breakthrough singles "Tim McGraw," "Teardrops on My Guitar," and "Our Song" to deep cuts like "Cold As You" and "Tied Together with a Smile," each song captures the raw emotions of adolescence with remarkable authenticity. Whether you're drawn to the fiery revenge anthem "Picture to Burn," the heartfelt "Should've Said No," or the sweet nostalgia of "Mary's Song," this tier list lets you celebrate the album that started it all and debate which tracks deserve top placement.

(This description was AI-generated)

By Mudkip

Sweeter than Fiction Tier

A (Oh my what a marvelous tune) Tier

B (A perfectly good song) Tier

C (It isnt love it isnt hate its just indifference Tier

D (Is It Over Now?) Tier

E (I forgot that this existed) Tier

F (The Last Time I'll listen to this) Tier

Sad (This is me crying) Tier