For Her

My Green Light

New Money

Past Is Catching Up to Me

Roaring On

Only Tea

Shady

Absolute Rose

Beautiful Little Fool

New Money (Reprise)

Better Hold Tight

Made to Last

Finale: Roaring On

For Better or Worse

Valley of Ashes

The Met

Second-Hand Suit

La Dee Dah With You

God Sees Everything

Valley of Ashes (Reprise)

For Her (Reprise)

One-Way Road

Only Tea (Reprise)

For Better or Worse (Reprise)

Created Mar 17, 2026

Create your own the great gatsby songs rankings with this tier list. Place each item into S, A, B, C, or D tier, then share and see how your picks compare with the community.

By TierBuddy Community

S Tier

For Her
My Green Light
New Money
Past Is Catching Up to Me
Roaring On

A Tier

Only Tea
Shady
Absolute Rose

B Tier

Beautiful Little Fool
New Money (Reprise)
Better Hold Tight
Made to Last
Finale: Roaring On

C Tier

For Better or Worse
Go
Valley of Ashes
The Met
Second-Hand Suit
La Dee Dah With You
God Sees Everything
Valley of Ashes (Reprise)

D Tier

For Her (Reprise)
One-Way Road
Only Tea (Reprise)
For Better or Worse (Reprise)