What are the best toothpicks of all time? Rank them all with this toothpicks of all time tier list maker. Drag your favorites into S tier and drop the worst into D tier. Share your toothpicks of all time tier list on social media, compare rankings with friends, and see what other Americans think. The ultimate way to rank and debate toothpicks of all time online. Popular categories include health, products, oral-care, toothpicks.