Menu

Top American Halloween Candy Tier List

Divine
Hershey.jpeg - Top American Halloween Candy Tier List tier list item
Reeses.jpeg - Top American Halloween Candy Tier List tier list item
Almost Perfect
Rolos.jpeg - Top American Halloween Candy Tier List tier list item
Milkyway.jpeg - Top American Halloween Candy Tier List tier list item
Snickers.png - Top American Halloween Candy Tier List tier list item
Excellent
M&M.jpeg - Top American Halloween Candy Tier List tier list item
Very Good
Twix.jpeg - Top American Halloween Candy Tier List tier list item
Good
Musketeers.jpeg - Top American Halloween Candy Tier List tier list item
Skittles.jpeg - Top American Halloween Candy Tier List tier list item
Crunch.jpeg - Top American Halloween Candy Tier List tier list item
KitKat.jpeg - Top American Halloween Candy Tier List tier list item
Adequate
Sour Patch Kids.webp - Top American Halloween Candy Tier List tier list item
Nerds.webp - Top American Halloween Candy Tier List tier list item
Sub Par
Starburst.jpeg - Top American Halloween Candy Tier List tier list item
Why?
smarties.jpeg - Top American Halloween Candy Tier List tier list item
Airheads.jpeg - Top American Halloween Candy Tier List tier list item
Butterfinger.jpeg - Top American Halloween Candy Tier List tier list item
SweetTarts.jpeg - Top American Halloween Candy Tier List tier list item
An Affront to God
Laffy Taffy.jpeg - Top American Halloween Candy Tier List tier list item
CandyCorn.jpeg - Top American Halloween Candy Tier List tier list item
Tootsy rolls.webp - Top American Halloween Candy Tier List tier list item
Twizzlers
Twizzlers.jpeg - Top American Halloween Candy Tier List tier list item
Created Jun 10, 2026
Create your ultimate top american halloween candy tier list and rank everything from S tier to D tier. This top american halloween candy ranking tool lets you compare, vote, and share your tier list with the community. Looking for the best top american halloween candy? Use this tier list to settle the debate and see how your top american halloween candy rankings stack up against other users on TierBuddy.

By TierBuddy Community

Divine Tier

Almost Perfect Tier

Excellent Tier

Very Good Tier

Good Tier

Adequate Tier

Sub Par Tier

Why? Tier

An Affront to God Tier

Twizzlers Tier