Menu

Top Musical Theater Shows of All Time Tier List

S
Death Becomes Her
Beetlejuice
Dear Evan Hanson
Ride the Cyclone
The Rocky Horror Show
Heathers
Mean Girls
Phantom Of the Opera
Chicago
West Side Story
Beauty And The Beast
A
Falsettos
Kinky Boots
Bye Bye Birdie
Jesus Christ Superstar
Waitress
The Addams Family
Moulin Rouge!
The Book of Mormon
Oklahoma!
Little Shop of Horrors
Legally Blonde
Snoopy
Six
Into The Woods
Guys And Dolls
Cabaret
B
Dirty Dancing
Just In Time
On The Town
Urinetown
Grease
You're a Good Man Charlie Brown
Oliver!
Once Upon a Mattress
Newsies
Next To Normal
Gypsy
Les Mis
Sweeny Todd
Bonnie & Clyde
Singin' in the Rain
Hairspray
A Chorus Line
Matilda
D
Fiddler On The Roof
Footloose
James And the Giant Peach
Junie B. Jones
Alice By Heart
Tick, Tick... BOOM!
New Girl In Town
Nevermore
Hadestown
Pippin
The Lion King
Rent
Peter Pan
Young Frankenstein
Kiss Me, Kate
Little Fish
F
Descendants
Seussical!
In The Heights
Very Good Eddie
Mamma Mia!
Freaky Friday
Wonderland
Hercules
Knoxville
Uptown Girls
Yank!
Cats
King Kong
Up on the Roof
Paint Your Wagon
Redhead
IDK
Annie Get Your Gun
A Christmas Carol
Escape To Margaritaville
Elf!
You Never Know
White Christmas
Everybody's Talking About Jamie
Ring of Fire
Good News!
In Transit
Zombie Prom
Evil Dead
Is There a Life After High School
Come From Away
Under the Gaslight
Created May 21, 2026
Use this top musical theater shows of all time tier list to rank your favorites from best to worst. Drag items into S, A, B, C, or D tiers and share your top musical theater shows of all time rankings with friends. Whether you're debating the best top musical theater shows of all time or settling an argument, this tier list maker lets you create the perfect top musical theater shows of all time ranking and compare with other Americans on TierBuddy. Popular categories include musicals, theater, broadway, musical-theater.

By Daisy Hawton

S Tier

A Tier

B Tier

D Tier

F Tier

IDK Tier