Top Musical Theater Shows of All Time Tier List
S
Beetlejuice
A
B
D
F
IDK
Created Apr 16, 2026
Use this top musical theater shows of all time tier list to rank your favorites from best to worst. Drag items into S, A, B, C, or D tiers and share your top musical theater shows of all time rankings with friends. Whether you're debating the best top musical theater shows of all time or settling an argument, this tier list maker lets you create the perfect top musical theater shows of all time ranking and compare with other Americans on TierBuddy. Popular categories include musicals, theater, broadway, musical-theater.
Bye Bye Birdie
Beauty And The Beast
Cabaret
Chicago
Cats
Come From Away
Evil Dead
Alice By Heart
A Chorus Line
A Christmas Carol
Annie Get Your Gun
Dear Evan Hanson
Death Becomes Her
Descendants
Dirty Dancing
Elf!
Escape To Margaritaville
Everybody's Talking About Jamie
Falsettos
Fiddler On The Roof
Footloose
Freaky Friday
Good News!
In The Heights
In Transit
Is There a Life After High School
James And the Giant Peach
Jesus Christ Superstar
Junie B. Jones
Just In Time
King Kong
Pippin
Paint Your Wagon
Rent
Ride the Cyclone
Ring of Fire
Redhead
Six
The Addams Family
The Book of Mormon
The Lion King
The Rocky Horror Show
Tick, Tick... BOOM!
Urinetown
Uptown Girls
Under the Gaslight
Up on the Roof
Waitress
Wonderland
West Side Story
White Christmas
You're a Good Man Charlie Brown
You Never Know
Young Frankenstein
Grease
Guys And Dolls
Gypsy
Hadestown
Hairspray
Heathers
Hercules
Into The Woods
Kinky Boots
Kiss Me, Kate
Knoxville
Legally Blonde
Les Mis
Little Shop of Horrors
Little Fish
Mamma Mia!
Moulin Rouge!
Matilda
Mean Girls
Newsies
Next To Normal
Nevermore
New Girl In Town
Oklahoma!
Oliver!
Once Upon a Mattress
On The Town
Peter Pan
Phantom Of the Opera
Snoopy
Singin' in the Rain
Sweeny Todd
Seussical!
Very Good Eddie
Yank!
Bonnie & Clyde
Zombie Prom